Introduction
If you run a Shopify store and want to rank higher on Google, you’ve likely faced this question: Should you hire a Shopify SEO consultant or sign a contract with an SEO agency? Both options can help optimize your store, bring in more traffic, and ultimately increase sales—but which one is the better fit for your specific needs?
Shopify SEO Consultant vs. SEO Agency: Let’s break it down clearly, so you can make the right decision.
What is a Shopify SEO Consultant?
A Shopify SEO consultant is an individual expert who specializes in improving search engine rankings for Shopify stores. They often work solo or with a small team and bring a personalized, one-on-one approach to your SEO.
Common services:
-
Keyword research
-
Technical SEO audits
-
On-page and off-page optimization
-
Store speed and performance improvement
-
SEO strategy tailored to Shopify’s structure
A consultant is ideal if you’re looking for focused attention, need help with a specific SEO issue, or want to keep your budget in check.
What is an SEO Agency?
An SEO agency is a larger, structured team offering a wide range of SEO services—often beyond just Shopify. They usually have departments for content writing, technical optimization, link building, analytics, and more.
Common services:
-
Full-suite SEO campaigns
-
Dedicated account management
-
Content strategy and writing
-
Advanced technical support
-
Competitor analysis and market research
An agency is best suited for brands that want to scale quickly, need a team of experts, or prefer a hands-off approach.
Key Differences at a Glance
When comparing a Shopify SEO consultant to an SEO agency, several differences stand out. Consultants typically offer a high level of personalization and direct communication, making them more adaptable and responsive to your specific business needs. They are generally more cost-effective and flexible in execution, but may have limited scalability. On the other hand, SEO agencies tend to follow a structured workflow, often communicating through an account manager. While they come at a higher cost, agencies offer a broader scope of services beyond just Shopify and are better equipped to scale with growing businesses.
When to Choose a Shopify SEO Consultant
A consultant is a great choice if:
-
You’re a small to mid-sized business with a clear focus on Shopify.
-
You need custom solutions and hands-on support.
-
You’re on a tight budget and want results without large retainers.
-
You already have an in-house team and just need guidance or auditing.
-
You’re an early-stage company and want to build a solid SEO foundation.
Consultants are often former agency employees or niche experts. They can provide deep Shopify-specific knowledge and agility that larger agencies sometimes lack.
When to Choose an SEO Agency
An agency might be the right call if:
-
You need multiple SEO disciplines working together (technical, content, PR, etc.).
-
Your Shopify store is rapidly scaling, and you want a team to keep up.
-
You prefer a set-it-and-forget-it approach, with regular updates but minimal involvement.
-
You require reporting dashboards, advanced analytics, and constant optimization.
-
You want to outsource everything related to SEO and marketing.
Agencies have systems, workflows, and multiple experts to cover your needs from every angle. This is great for growing stores or those that are already well-established.
Cost Comparison
-
Consultants: Typically charge between $500–$2,500/month, depending on scope.
-
Agencies: Can range from $1,500–$10,000+/month, especially for full-service plans.
Don’t just look at the number—consider ROI. A consultant might deliver more value per dollar in certain cases, while an agency may be worth the investment for long-term scaling.
Hybrid Options: The Best of Both Worlds?
Some store owners hire a Shopify SEO consultant first, then move to an agency as they grow. Others combine both—consultants for audits and oversight, and agencies for execution.
If your budget allows, this hybrid strategy can be powerful. You get deep expertise and the muscle to implement at scale.
Conclusion
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. A Shopify SEO consultant offers expertise, flexibility, and affordability. An SEO agency delivers breadth, scalability, and team support. Your choice depends on your business size, goals, and how involved you want to be in the SEO process.
Whatever you choose, investing in SEO for your Shopify store is one of the smartest long-term moves you can make.
